Every Friday morning, I join the Cardle & Woolley Show on 1370 Talk Radio in Austin to announce the week’s Winners & Losers. Texas lawmakers, who make just $7,200 a year, will be working over Memorial Day weekend to finish up the current session, but their counterparts in Congress, who make $174,000 annually, are off for the Memorial Day recess. Go figure. Here’s who made the list this week:
WINNER: Trump’s Big Beautiful Bill Clears House
As a constituent of one of the leading GOP critics of Trump’s reconciliation bill, U.S. Rep. Chip Roy, R-Texas, I am both familiar and sympathetic with the strong argument that the massive budget legislation dangerously increases both the debt and the deficit. But in my view, those arguments are outweighed by the critical need to ensure that Trump’s tax cuts are maintained and that tips and overtime will be tax exempt going forward. In tax reform, one goal for conservatives always has to be changing the culture so that taxpayers vividly see just how much of their money the government takes in taxes.
Ultimately, Rep. Roy voted for the bill, despite his continued concern that much more fiscal restraint is needed. He’s totally right about that, but remember that, aside from immigration, one of the best arguments against voting for Kamala Harris last year was her promise to let the Trump tax cuts expire. With this House vote, the odds are very good Republicans aren’t going to let that happen.
LOSER: Hillary Clinton Attacks Conservative Women
Not that anyone cares, but this week failed presidential candidate Hillary Clinton attacked, calling “most” conservative women “handmaidens of the patriarchy.” There’s no point in pushing back on such a stupid remark, but it is important to note that a woman who married her way into a political career has no room to talk about the patriarchy.
LOSER: Biden Cover-Up Still on Big Loser List
After Jake Tapper and Alex Thompson’s book, “Original Sin,” made a big splash last week, I assumed the issue of former President Joe Biden’s cognitive decline in office would finally rotate off Winners and Losers. Surely, that horse has been sufficiently beaten. But then the tapes of Biden’s deposition by Special Counsel Robert Hur were released and America could actually hear just how disoriented the former president was. His sense of time, his focus, his grasp on reality—all demonstrated that Hur had been right when he said that although Biden had broken the law regarding classified documents, he was so feeble and forgetful that no jury would convict him.
The Hur tapes further validated the information in Tapper’s book about how the White House staff misled the public about Biden’s competence. The Joe Biden revealed on those tapes was the same Joe Biden who his advisors said was sharp as a tack.
Finally, it wasn’t just conservatives who were asking, “Who was running the country?”
Then, just before that question could be seriously considered, Biden’s spokespeople announced that the former president has “Stage 4 prostate cancer that has metastasized to his bones.”
That is terrible news for the former president and his family and virtually everyone, including President Trump and Biden’s harshest critics in conservative media, have profusely and repeatedly expressed their concerns and offered their prayers.
Unfortunately for the Biden family, after the Tapper book and the Hur tapes, they are no longer trusted by anyone, so this awful news doesn’t just evoke sympathy, it raises more questions: Men his age are routinely screened for prostate cancer. If Biden wasn’t, why not?
Biden said he had cancer in 2022, but his staff said he misspoke. Did he? Did the family know Biden had cancer and not tell the country? Did Biden know he had cancer when he was insisting that he would run for re-election again? Did Jill Biden and Hunter know? Did his advisors, the so-called “Politburo” who were apparently making all the presidential decisions, know? Or, was Biden somehow unlucky enough to have a personal physician who missed a crucial point on the former president’s regular check-up? Texas Sen. John Cornyn has asked DOJ to investigate “potential violations of federal law regarding representations made to the general public about the president’s health.
Going forward, historians will undoubtedly debate whether the Biden cover-up was just a sequence of bad decisions made expediently, or if voters had unknowingly put a Richard III in the Oval Office where he and his advisors would do whatever it took to keep the White House.
In the short term, a good question for the media to ponder is how did the former president so completely destroy the public’s trust that even a tragic cancer diagnosis raises justified suspicion?
WINNER: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer
Starmer and the British Labour Party have been on the wrong side of immigration for decades, but when it finally became undeniably clear that they would stop winning elections unless they dramatically changed course, Starmer came out this week saying open immigration has created a “squalid chapter for the economy and the country,” adding that mass migration has turned England into an “island of strangers.”
Perhaps Starmer has been watching Trump or listening to Vice President J.D. Vance, but immigration issues in England finally upended British politics not only because importing cheap labor alienated the working class but also because such a high percentage of migrants are Muslim. Many British communities are no longer recognizable and this is also surely what Starmer was referring to when he said that the country’s open borders had created a “rise of forces that are slowly pulling the country apart.” Over 80 Sharia law courts have been established in England, where many Muslims adjudicate family law issues including marriages and divorces, outside the British legal system.
Unlike American Democrats, Starmer and his Labour Party understand that they only have their selves to blame for their immigration policies. Starmer is a human rights lawyer who spent his career blocking the deportation of foreign-born criminals and other illegal immigrants. But finally, as Prime Minister, Starmer has seen the light and is pledging to close the borders down.
WINNER: Four Polls Show Trump’s Positive Approvals are Up
Polls go up and down and President Trump’s high-energy approach to his job causes his ratings to be erratic. With the legacy media only headlining the low numbers, it’s sometimes hard to get a decent snapshot of what Americans are thinking. However, this week it is worth noting that four opinion polls showed the President with positive ratings at the same time. The Morning Consult Poll had Trump’s approval at 48, HarvardCAPS /Harris poll shows him at a net positive, Rasmussen has him at 50%, just like the Daily Mail/J.L. Partners poll.
LOSER: Grade Inflation in Grievance Studies Programs
While testifying recently in support of Senate Bill 37, the higher education reform bill authored by Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe and Rep. Matt Shaheen, R-Plano, I informed lawmakers that over 400 courses at University of Texas at Austin include gender in the title, 200 purport to be about race and 150 focus on identity. By comparison, less than a dozen courses focus on the Constitution, the Federalist Papers or President Abraham Lincoln. When one of the lawmakers asked why, I noted that students take these courses because they are frequently an easy “A.” The audience at the hearing was filled with faculty, mostly from UT Austin, who opposed the legislation and mocked my response, some by laughing and making derogatory comments out loud. One yelled out, “you need to take a course,” before the chairman gaveled them out of order.
But a study released this week by the America First Policy Institute confirmed that at UT Austin, activist-driven classes, “particularly those found in ethnic, gender, and identity-focused studies—are less academically demanding and contribute disproportionately to grade inflation.” In women’s studies classes, for example, 85% of students receive an A. TPPF is supporting legislation, House Bill 4234, that will make this transparent by noting on individual transcripts what grades are given in a class—so a student whose transcript reports an A will also be informed that 85% of the class also made an A.
SB 37 will restore the authority of Boards of Regents at state run college and universities in Texas and rein in the hegemony of faculty control over the courses that are taught.
LOSER: No Paris Trip for Harris County Judge
The Harris County Commissioners Court has voted against providing funds for County Judge Lina Hidalgo and four of her staff to travel to Paris on a “trade mission.” Hidalgo is a Democrat, and two Democrats joined with Republicans in giving a thumbs down to the Paris trip, noting that the Harris County budget has a deficit of at least $131 million.
Meanwhile, Houston Mayor John Whitmire announced he had no interest in going to France, and put out a budget this week that increases police pay without a budget deficit. Just saying.
LOSER: Man Takes Women’s Swimming Medals in Texas
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton announced this week that he is investigating what happened at the U.S. Masters Swimming Spring Nationals when a man who says he’s a woman took first place in five events at the meet which was held in San Antonio recently. The man, Hugo Caldas, won the 50-yard breaststroke, the 100-yard breaststroke, the 50-yard freestyle, the 100-yard freestyle, and 100-yard individual combination.
According to a United Nations report “more than 600 biologically female athletes have lost at least 890 medals to transgender competitors in 29 sports. This is ok with U.S. Masters Swimming, but it is not allowed in Texas, so it is good Paxton is on the case.
WINNER: Texas Still No. 1 Job Creating State
This feels like old news, but Gov. Greg Abbott announced this week that the Bureau of Labor Statistics continues to show that Texas is the top job creating state in the nation. Texas added 37,700 jobs in April and over 215,000 jobs last year. Abbott adds that since he has been governor, over 2 million jobs have been created in Texas.
LOSER: Texas A&M Leads SEC in Coach Payouts
Meanwhile, we learned this week that that Texas A&M led the Southeastern Conference (SEC) in coach buyouts in 2024 with $27.5 million spent to buy out the contracts of losing coaches. A&M’s big number was driven by the $19.2 million the Aggies gave Jimbo Fisher in 2023. The University of Texas at Austin paid $7.2 million to buy out the contracts of losing coaches there.
WINNER: NBA Small Markets … and the Knicks
For those who don’t tune into NBA basketball until the playoffs, now is the time. We’re down to the final four—the East and West Championships, where small market teams—the Minnesota Timberwolves and Oklahoma City—are battling in the West and the Indiana Pacers are playing in the East. This is a big boost for teams in relatively small media markets. The once-legendary New York Knicks, who knocked off the reigning champions, the Boston Celtics, just the other week, are obviously in the biggest media market on the planet. All the teams are playing throughout the long holiday weekend.
Have a great Memorial Day!
Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.
Sign up to receive this in your inbox every week at www.texaspolicy.com/9thandCongress.
Follow me on X @sylvester1630 and follow my podcast, the Sherry Sylvester Show on Apple, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.