Categories
Winners & Losers

9th & Congress: Winners & Losers – April 19, 2024

We have to shift the focus off Texas for a minute to declare that the week’s big winner is Israel. The weekend attack on Israel directly from Iran finally made it clear to foggy thinkers in both America and the world that what is going on in the Middle East is a war against Western Civilization. Israel didn’t “take the win” as the U.S. administration advised after it fended off the weekend attack. Instead, it fired back last night.

Shortly after the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel, two of my colleagues at TPPF, Chuck DeVore and Erin Valdez, along with Rabbi Dan Ain, discussed Iran’s role in the conflict and other issues. Six months later, almost nothing has changed. You can view the panel here.

The biggest losers of the week are Texas kids, who will continue to be able to find pornography in public school libraries after the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down a Texas law that would have required booksellers to rate books for sexual and violent content—just as movies are rated. The American Library Association, along with Texas librarian groups, falsely called the law a “book ban.” They celebrated the ruling and recently announced support for the most banned books in the country which include “All Boys Aren’t Blue” and “This Book is Gay.” “Gender Queer” is at the top of the list. If you haven’t read it and wonder if it belongs in a public school library, read my review here.

Texas Governor Greg Abbott is a winner for being named to Time’s list of the 100 Most Influential People in the World. Although the left-leaning magazine called it a “stunt,” they could not ignore the fact that Abbott showed the country and the world the true impact of an open border when he began busing illegal immigrants to so-called “sanctuary cities” in the north. Abbott successfully changed the narrative on illegal immigration from a border state concern to a top priority in many of the nation’s largest cities.

Former President Donald Trump also made it to the winners list for his visit to a Harlem bodega after his court date in New York City this week that drew crowds and cheers. Following up on his successful visit to a Chick-fil-A in Atlanta last week, Trump again demonstrated that he knows more about how the media works than almost anyone—including the media.

There’s lots for conservatives not to like about Google, but it made the Winners List this week for firing 28 employees who staged a sit-in at Google’s New York and Sunnyvale, California offices to protest a Google computer contract with Israel. A great quote from Google CEO said Googlers need to be “more focused in how we work, collaborate, discuss and even disagree.”

Texas property taxpayers continue to be big losers as they bankroll the cushy salaries of public school superintendentsCypress-Fairbanks ISD, outside Houston, always tops the list. Their superintendent hauls in $546,000 a year, one of eight Texas superintendents who make close to a half million annually. Another 81 make more than $300,000. It might be easier to swallow if these same superintendents didn’t constantly show up at the Texas Legislature, hat in hand, insisting their schools are underfunded.

University of Texas at Austin students and faculty also made the Losers List for demanding that UT officials roll back the firing of almost 60 DEI officers by staging a campus protest. Fewer than 200 people out of 52,000 students showed up for the protest. The spokesperson was the head of UT Austin’s Queer Trans Black Indigenous People of Color Agency who said her group was not happy with the direction the university is going. But I’m betting the taxpayers of Texas who put $53 billion into higher education last session are ok with it.

Two more winners. Uri Berliner, a Senior Editor at National Public Radio, resigned this week after being sanctioned by NPR for pointing out that the outlet is biased and has lost the public’s trust. Berliner’s expose was not really news. NPR hasn’t had the public’s trust for years. In fact, I admit I giggled when Berliner reported that he took the time to check the voter registration of almost 100 of his colleagues in Washington, D.C. and was shocked to learn that all of them were registered Democrats. NPR’s CEO Katherine Maher, apparently no fan of free speech, didn’t try to make a case that NPR is unbiased. Instead, she called Berliner’s expose “hurtful and demeaning.” U.S. Sen. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., is pushing to defund NPR so taxpayers don’t have to fund this nonsense.

Finally, Shaquille O’Neal makes the Winners List for refusing to join the grievance chorus lamenting that women’s basketball stars including Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese, who were just drafted into the WNBA, make only a fraction of what NBA players do. Shaq rightly says that fans need to show their support. The bottom line is that men’s basketball makes lots more money than women’s basketball. When that changes, salaries will change. Want to support the WNBA? Buy tickets, buy fan gear, watch the games!

Listen to Winners & Losers on the Cardle & Woolley show every Friday morning at 8:30 AM on 1370 Talk Radio in Austin. Listen live online here.

Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.

Sign up to receive this in your inbox every week at www.texaspolicy.com/9thandCongress.

Follow me on X @sylvester1630 and follow my podcast, the Sherry Sylvester Show on AppleSpotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

Categories
In The Media

Texas Holding Universities Accountable on DEI

This commentary was originally published in Townhall.

Texas Longhorns were stunned when the news broke that the University of Texas at Austin had fired as many as 60 employees connected to so-called “Diversity, Equity and Inclusion” programs. A week prior to the firing, Texas Senate Education Committee Chairman Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, had alerted Texas universities that he would be calling them to the Capitol in May to provide an update on their progress in ridding Texas campuses of DEI.

With the support of Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, Creighton wrote the strongest anti-DEI legislation in the nation, and his letter reminded university leaders that failure to comply with the law could ultimately affect their funding.

DEI is the acronym for “Diversity, Equity and Inclusion” a deceptively named race-based ideology that divides people into two groups—oppressors, who are mostly white people, although increasingly Jews and Asians are included in the oppressor group—and victims, who are African American, Hispanic or gay. Sometimes women are included in the victim group, though rarely white women. Victims also include those who are suffering from gender dysphoria.

DEI advocates have been working for more than a decade to re-segregate university campuses in Texas and across the country so “victims” aren’t required to interact with “oppressors” in classes and activities. Many Texas universities have segregated graduations for Black students and Hispanic students. “Lavender graduations” are held for gay students.

Arguing in favor of DEI programs, a student at the University of Texas at Austin, where only 5.5 percent of students are African-American despite two decades of DEI programs, said, “I don’t feel like I go to a (predominately white institution) because I’m always around my Black friends”

Imagine if a white student boasted, “I don’t feel like I go to a racially integrated university because I only hang out with my white friends.”

There has been massive blowback on Texas campuses following the passage of Senate Bill 17. The Austin-American Statesman reported that both students and faculty are rattled, exhausted and confused. DEI has infiltrated every aspect of university life, because it seems administrators have been allowed to put forward almost anything in the name of DEI without assessing the impact on students or its relevance to the educational mission of the academic institution.

For example, in a move that harkens back to the “Whites Only” signs before the Civil Rights Act, in the name of DEI, at least one flagship university established separate study rooms in the library for only LGBTQ students. When the library was crowded, other students were required to sit on the floor—whether the separate study rooms had people in them or not.

Students at Texas A&M lamented that when the so-called “Pride Center” closed down, there would be no place for women students to get binders to smash down their breasts so they looked like men. But administrators at the University of Texas at Dallas bragged that they were able to keep their “transition closet” open to provide cross-dressing outfits and supplies for students who believe they are the other gender. The officials insist they are now using “transition” as a broader term.

When the University of Texas announced that it would change the name of the Gender and Sexuality Center to the “Women’s Community Center,” it stated its mission was to provide “a place for Longhorns of all genders to connect, find resources, and get support around experiences of intersectionality, community, and gender solidarity.”

“Longhorns of all genders?” Clearly, they just didn’t get it. Leaders of the Women’s Community Center are among those who are being let go. Other campuses have also been slow to respond.

An official at Texas A&M was caught on tape saying that DEI programs were simply being “rebranded.” At the University of Texas at Tyler, an administrator said they were getting around SB 17 by “being creative.” At Texas Tech, an administrator said DEI programs were now all operating under the Campus Access and Engagement program.

Sen. Creighton made clear in his letter to university leaders that none of this is permissible under the law.

These frantic administrators who are clinging to DEI seem unaware that the biggest indictment against it is that it doesn’t work. A British study is the latest to reveal what we have seen in Texas—DEI makes no difference in increasing the recruitment of minority and marginalized students or improving their academic outcomes or career opportunities. In Texas, shutting down racially divisive and ineffective DEI policies wasn’t a suggestion—it is Texas law that could cost them their funding.

Categories
Winners & Losers

9th & Congress: Winners & Losers – April 12, 2024

Every Friday morning at 8:30 a.m., I discuss the week’s Winners & Losers on the Cardle & Woolley show on Austin’s 1370 Talk Radio. It’s a lightning round with Jim Cardle, Lynn Woolley and me that runs the gambit from public policy and political trends to sports and culture in Texas, America and the world. You can listen to the segment with everybody’s comments by clicking the 8:30 a.m. segment here.

For the week of April 8 to 12, unfortunately my list begins with the powers that be in Washington, D.C.

The U.S.’s ever-weakening support for Israel escalated this week when President Joe Biden put out his own call to Hamas for a six-week ceasefire. Not sure what happened to the “we don’t negotiate with terrorists” principle, but whatever. The president’s bid to give Hamas a chance to reload didn’t even pretend to be linked to the release of any hostages. Hamas rejected the U.S. offer and America is now busy making it clear to the world that our support for Israel is more than a little mushy. Add that to the news that administration-induced inflation that continues to trend upward at 3.5% impacting not just food and basic necessities, but insurance and car repairs. Mortgage rates are at 7%! Then there’s the administration’s continuing attempts to pander to younger people with a student loan bailout that has a floating price tag of somewhere between $76 billion and $500 billion. The cost to every taxpayer is estimated at over $3,500.

Well, maybe not every taxpayer if Dallas Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett, R-Dallas, gets her way. She suggested this week that Black people be exempted from paying taxes as a back door to racial reparations. That really terrible idea has earned her a place on the Losers List.

But let’s not plunge into a negative spiral. There were lots of winners this week, including Texas, where the number of millionaires in the state has increased 47% since 2021. Texas’ conservative formula of low taxes, reasonable regulation and fair courts continues to make our great state ground central for prosperity.

In a related win, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick issued his interim charges for the next legislative session, which include a number of initiatives that underscore our conservative principles and ensure that Texas will continue to lead the nation in job creation, business innovation, productivity and growth.

Chick-fil-A was a big winner this week when it became a visual confirmation of the latest findings of a new Wall Street Journal poll showing former President Donald Trump’s continued increasing support among African Americans. Amidst a flurry of Trump’s buying free milkshakes for the house, an African American woman proudly told the former president, “I don’t care what the media tells you, we support you.”

Another big winner this week was Pope Francis, who declared transgender surgery a violation of human dignity, making the moral high ground official, for anyone who had doubts. The Pontiff’s move comes as the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA) announced that it is banning men from women’s sports—a big win for women athletes at smaller schools. In what should be a new spirit of inclusivity, the NAIA announced that anybody can play in men’s sports—real men, fake men, even women who think they are men.

Of course, South Carolina won the NCAA Women’s Basketball championship on Sunday, drawing millions more viewers for the big game than the men’s final. It was marred only by its coach, Dawn Staley, who earned a spot on the Losers List by saying before the game that anyone who “feels like a woman” should be able to play in women’s sports. South Carolina Congresswoman Nancy Mace called Staley out on it, asking how she would feel if she’d been beaten by a team that had a male player on it. Perhaps Mace was thinking that some guy could block Staley’s MVP, the 6’7” Kamilla Cardoso. The average height in the NBA is 6’6”. The WNBA height average is 6’. Mace rightly called Staley’s statement “absolute lunacy,” earning her a spot on the Winners List.

Other Weekly Winners:

Dan Crenshaw who called out Tucker Carlson for his latest insistence that the U.S. should stop helping Israel because it is killing Christians in Gaza.

Uri Berliner, a long time editor at National Public Radio (NPR), who reported in the Free Press this week how NPR went woke and lost its audience. Similar to James Bennet’s piece in the Economist on the New York Times late last year, Berliner details the process of journalists going from reporters to activists who push a politically correct ideology instead of facts. He talks of being ignored when he suggested NPR should stop calling Florida’s ban on sex education for preschoolers the “Don’t Say Gay” law since the legislation doesn’t even include the word gay. He said a respected NPR reporter told his colleagues they should not cover the Hunter Biden laptop story because it would “help Trump.”

FinallyEclipse Losers 

Central Texans only got a bit of an eclipse view because of the cloud cover, but Houston Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee shone a whole new light on the celestial phenomenon. Jackson explained to students at Booker T. Washington High School that the moon is a planet made up of gases. She has thoughts on the sun too, but her astronomical theories are too complex to explain. I encourage you to read the news report and then listen to her entire theory on the solar system here.

Meanwhile, Sunny Hostin, on The View, blamed the eclipse, the New Jersey earthquake and cicadas on global warming.

Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.

Sign up to receive this in your inbox every week at www.texaspolicy.com/9thandCongress.

Follow me on X @sylvester1630 and follow my podcast, the Sherry Sylvester Show on AppleSpotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

Categories
Sherry Sylvester Show

The Sherry Sylvester Show | Episode 25: A New Generation of Leadership with Caroline Fairly

TPPF’s Sherry Sylvester sits down with Caroline Fairly, the GOP Nominee for Texas House District 87 (centered in Amarillo and encompassing Potter and seven surrounding counties) to discuss the issues facing Gen Z and possible solutions… if they have the courage to pursue them!

Listen to the Sherry Sylvester Show on Apple or Spotify.

Categories
Sherry Sylvester Show

The Sherry Sylvester Show | Episode 24: Women’s Rights Champion, Sen. Lois Kolkhorst

“Live from TPS,” TPPF’s Sherry Sylvester sits down with Texas Senator Lois Kolkhorst to discuss the battles fought to protect female athletes in the state, and the new forces rising up against those efforts in the name of “diversity, equity, and inclusion.”

Listen to the Sherry Sylvester Show on Apple or Spotify.

Subscribe to the 9th & Congress newsletter.

Categories
Winners & Losers

9th & Congress: Winners & Losers – April 5, 2024

Every Friday morning at 8:30 a.m., I discuss the week’s Winners & Losers on the Cardle & Woolley show on Austin’s 1370 Talk Radio. It’s a lightning round with Jim Cardle, Lynn Woolley and me that runs the gambit from public policy and political trends to sports and culture in Texas, America and the world. You can listen to the segment with everybody’s comments by clicking the 8:30 a.m. segment here.

Here’s the highlights from my Winners & Losers list for the week of March 30 to April 5:

Big Winner of the Week: The University of Texas at Austin for firing an estimated 60 employees who worked in so-called “Diversity, Equity and Inclusion” (DEI) programs and projects at UT. Following up on a letter from State Senator Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, the Longhorns took the most visible action of any college or university in the state so far to follow the state’s anti-DEI law, Senate Bill 17 which requires that DEI be ended at taxpayer-funded universities.

Big Loser of the Week: The $20 an hour minimum wage requirement that kicked in in California. This job-killing (and likely small business-killing) proposal will hit young workers particularly hard and is another demonstration that the big blue state on the West Coast hasn’t a clue how the economy actually works.

Other Big Winners:

British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak backed Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling’s pushing back on Scotland’s new expanded hate speech laws. The laws make it a crime to “misgender” a man who insists he is a woman but has no protections for actual women. Rowling has shined a spotlight on transgender criminals who have raped and assaulted women when they insist on being detained in women’s prisons. Sunak said it was not a crime to state the “actual facts of biology” and that his Conservative Party supports free speech.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott gets a big thumbs up for his trip to the Big Apple to speak to the New York GOP Gala. Abbott continues to get accolades for busing illegal migrants to sanctuary cities—exposing them as simply “sanctimonious cities” —and showing the rest of the country what it is like to be overrun at our southern border.

Fort Worth is now the home of Texas’ newest TV station, Merit Street, a national outlet that is anchored by Dr. Phil. Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick and State Sen. Tan Parker, R-Flower Mound, were on hand for the ribbon cutting.

More DEI Losers: 

The NAACP is a big loser for urging black athletes to boycott the state of Florida because of Florida’s laws banning DEI. Florida also bans teaching gender and sexuality studies to young children. Early reports indicate most black athletes are ignoring the boycott. More than 35 African-American football stars have recently announced they are committed to Florida teams. If you recall, when the NAACP first issued its “travel warning” to African Americans for Florida last year, it was revealed that several of its executives actually lived in the Sunshine State. Here’s part of the NAACP’s statement:

“Please be advised that Florida is openly hostile toward African Americans, people of color and LGBTQ+ individuals. Before traveling to Florida, please understand that the State of Florida devalues and marginalizes the contributions of and the challenges faced by African Americans and other minorities.”

Another DEI loser is Harvard’s Office of Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Belonging which announced more segregated graduation ceremonies this week including a “Disability Celebration,” a “Global Indigenous Celebration,” an “Asian American, Pacific Islander, Desi-American (APIDA) Celebration,” a “First Generation-Low Income Celebration,” a “Jewish Celebration,” a “Latinx Celebration,” a “Lavender Celebration”—which refers to LGBT students—a “Black Celebration,” a “Veterans Celebration,” and an “Arab Celebration.” If diversity is the goal, why is everybody being segregated into homogeneous groups?

NCAA Final Four is the Final Big Winner of the Week – Both the men’s and women’s bracket have been full of really great games. There have been lots of busted brackets and no Texas teams made it to the final round, but this weekend’s lineup of men and women from both NC State and UConn, along with Alabama and South Carolina, will be big fun!

Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.

Sign up to receive this in your inbox every week at www.texaspolicy.com/9thandCongress.

Follow me on X @sylvester1630 and follow my podcast, the Sherry Sylvester Show on AppleSpotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

Categories
9th & Congress

State Sen. Brandon Creighton’s Bill Ending DEI Was Not a Suggestion

Senate Education Chairman Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, has alerted Texas universities that he will be calling them to the Capitol in May to provide an update on their progress in ridding Texas campuses of DEI, as required by Senate Bill 17. With the support of Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, Creighton wrote the strongest anti-DEI legislation in the nation and his letter reminds university leaders that failure to comply with the law could ultimately affect their funding.

To be clear on what Sen. Creighton is talking about, DEI is the acronym for “Diversity, Equity and Inclusion,” a deceptively named race-based ideology that divides people into two groups—oppressors, who are mostly white people, although increasingly Jews and Asians are included in the oppressor group, and victims, who are African American, Hispanic or gay. Sometimes women are included in the victim group, though rarely white women. Victims also include those who are suffering from gender dysphoria.

DEI advocates have been working for over a decade to re-segregate university campuses in Texas and across the country so “victims” aren’t required to interact with “oppressors” in classes and activities. Many Texas universities have segregated graduations for Black students and Hispanic students. “Lavender graduations” are held for gay students.

Arguing in favor of DEI programs, a student at the University of Texas at Austin, where only 5.5 percent of students are African-American despite two decades of DEI programs, said, “I don’t feel like I go to a (predominately white institution) because I’m always around my Black friends.”

Imagine if a white student boasted, “I don’t feel like I go to a racially integrated university because I only hang out with my white friends.”

There has been massive blowback on Texas campuses following the passage of Senate Bill 17. The Austin-American Statesman reported that both students and faculty are rattled, exhausted and confused. DEI has infiltrated every aspect of university life because it seems administrators have put forward almost anything in the name of DEI without assessing the impact on students and its relevance to the educational mission of the academic institution.

For example, in a move that harkens back to the “Whites Only” signs before the Civil Rights Act, in the name of DEI, at least one flagship university established separate study rooms in the library for only LGBTQ students. When the library was crowded, other students were required to sit on the floor whether the separate study rooms had people in them or not.

Students at Texas A&M lamented that when the so-called “Pride Center” closed down there would be no place for women students to get binders to smash down their breasts so they looked like men. But administrators at the University of Texas at Dallas bragged that they were able to keep their “transition closet” open to provide cross-dressing outfits and supplies for students who believe they are the other gender. The officials insist they are now using “transition” as a broader term.

When the University of Texas announced that it would change the name of the Gender and Sexuality Center to the “Women’s Community Center,” it stated its mission was to provide “a place for Longhorns of all genders to connect, find resources, and get support around experiences of intersectionality, community, and gender solidarity.”

“Longhorns of all genders?” The wacky notion that there are Longhorns who are some gender other than male or female, like the evil idea that it is good for black students to only hang out with other black students, are two of the prime directives of DEI that permeate campus culture. Instilling these beliefs and others rooted in critical race and gender theory is the mission of DEI at every level.

The Chronicle of Higher Education recently published a survey of a number of Texas universities and found some leaders were taking comprehensive steps to adhere to Senate Bill 17. But change will not be quick.

An official at Texas A&M was caught on tape saying that DEI programs were simply being “rebranded.” At the University of Texas at Tyler, an administrator said they were getting around SB 17 by “being creative.” At Texas Tech, an administrator said DEI programs were now all operating under the Campus Access and Engagement program.

Sen. Creighton made clear in his letter to university leaders that none of this is permissible under the law.

These frantic administrators who are clinging to DEI seem unaware that the biggest indictment against it is that it doesn’t work. A British study is the latest to reveal what we have seen in Texas—DEI makes no difference in increasing the recruitment of minority and marginalized students or improving their academic outcomes or career opportunities. Sen. Creighton is right to remind university leaders across the state that the mandate of SB 17 to shut down these racially divisive and ineffective DEI policies isn’t a suggestion—it is Texas law, and could cost them their funding.

Sherry Sylvester is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, and the former Senior Advisor to Texas Lt. Governor Dan Patrick.

Categories
Sherry Sylvester Show

The Sherry Sylvester Show | Episode 23: Dr. Walter Wendler on Academic Leadership

Live from Texas Policy Summit 2024, TPPF’s Sherry Sylvester sits down with the President of West Texas A&M University, Dr. Walter Wendler to discuss what is needed in today’s academic leaders in order to prepare Gen Z for what the future has in store for them.

Listen to the Sherry Sylvester Show on Apple or Spotify.

Subscribe to the 9th & Congress newsletter.

Categories
In The Media

TPS 2024 – Winning the War on Woke

States like Texas and Florida are fighting back against the left’s radical ideology that permeates nearly every major American institution. The panel discusses the success conservatives are having and the where the battle moves next.

To watch more videos from the 2024 Texas Policy Summit, click here.

Categories
9th & Congress

The War Against History Continues in Texas

Wokeness won’t go away quietly, especially in the war against history. In April, a new Texas history organization, created in the aftermath of a critical race showdown within the Texas State Historical Association (TSHA), announced it will meet for its first symposium, titled “Texas History in the 21st Century: Looking Back, Moving Forward.”

At this event, to be held at Texas Christian University, college professors can learn about “Writing Against the Master Narrative,” as well as pay tribute to former TSHA Chief Historian, Walter Buenger.

One doesn’t have to read too closely between the lines to get the impression that these historians, almost exclusively academics, apparently believe that there’s some kind of “master narrative” that needs to be challenged.

You may recall that their honoree, Buenger, has dismissed the Alamo as “insignificant,” while insisting that the shrine of Texas liberty has been misused to “commemorate whiteness.”

Is that the “master narrative?”

From commentary in the media, it is clear that this new group believes they are up against the Texas Legislature, which rightly banned the teaching of the 1619 Project—after it had been debunked by seemingly every reputable historian in the country.

Perhaps they also believe it is important to put the book “Forget the Alamo”—written by two partisan reporters and a political consultant, which was also debunked by any historian that matters—in Texas classrooms?

Because they are professors, they may also be fighting against the Texas Legislature’s passage of a ban on diversity, equity and inclusion offices and programs in Texas public colleges and universities. The Texas DEI bill has nothing to do with teaching history, but it does prohibit classifying every student by the color of their skin, ethnicity, or gender.

DEI ideology on campus permeates every aspect of campus life, especially the teaching of history. It is built on a flawed and racially divisive view of history that allows for only one lens—race and oppression. It’s a worldview that encourages people to make ridiculous statements, such as claiming the story of the Alamo “commemorates whiteness.”

DEI is a simplistic attempt to reduce Texas history, American history—the history of all Western civilization—into a war between villains and heroes. Using their analysis, every hero (in the so-called “master narrative”) is a villain and consequently, every villain must be made into a hero.

(To see how this works in contemporary times, just look at how campuses—students and faculty alike—made heroes out of the terrorists who attacked Israel.)

Real historians cannot be driven by a political ideology. They know that no figure from the past, not one as saintly as Francis of Assisi nor one as despicable as Benedict Arnold, can be portrayed as either fully hero or villain. Human beings are complicated, and so must their historical reckoning be. The shameful institution of slavery did exist in Texas, and no teacher of history can shy away from that. That’s why Texas teachers are required to teach about slavery, reconstruction, Jim Crow and the Civil Rights era.

Texans, like all Americans, have not always lived up to the ideals established at Washington on the Brazos. But we have never lost sight of them either.

Here at TPPF, our award-winning “Forging Texas” film series tells the story of the Texas Revolution—but it also tells the story of the first woman to lead a cattle drive across the Chisolm Trail, the Vietnamese migration to Texas in the 1970s and, most recently, investigates the birth of the African American film industry in Texas with our film, “The Making of a Classic.”

The 1836 Advisory Project was established by the Texas Legislature in 2021 and has produced a Texas history summary that is available to everyone at State DMV offices. It covers all of Texas history—the good, the bad and the ugly. Even one of the authors of “Forget the Alamo,” called it “surprisingly accurate.”

Focus groups conducted by TPPF found that most residents of the Lone Star State, whether native-born or recently arrived, African American or Hispanic, are proud to call themselves Texans. They consider the Texas story to be their own story—a story of courage and struggle, striving and success. They certainly do not view it as a white-washed “master narrative.”

We can hope that the Texas Alliance for History doesn’t become just another group of grumbling, left-leaning professors trying to convince Texans that their great state that grew out of nothing to become the seventh largest economy in the world and the job creator for the nation is somehow an evil place.

Over a million people visit the Alamo every year, a site where 200 men courageously fought to the death to ensure that Texas would be independent and free. Some African Americans and abolitionists fought beside Travis and Crockett. Everyone who was there during the siege has a story, and true historians want to learn about all of them. No one who knows the story would describe the sacrifice at the Alamo as “insignificant.”